‘My cousin wants to name her baby after a plant – it’s awful’

This post may contain affiliate links that allow us to earn a commission at no expense to you. Learn more

My cousin has chosen to name her baby after a plant and I’m struggling to wrap my head around it.

Short Summary:

  • My cousin picks a plant-inspired name I find awful.
  • I previously shared my baby name with family, and now it’s been mirrored.
  • Our family dynamics have taken an unexpected twist.

A Name Worthy of a Plant: How My Cousin’s Baby Naming Stumped Us All

Choosing a baby name is a profound task; it’s more than just a moniker—it’s an identity. For many parents, it is also a chance to impart a story or familial legacy. But what happens when your chosen name causes more confusion and frustration than joy?

This exact scenario unfolded recently when my cousin decided to name her unborn daughter after a plant. Now, I’m wrestling with my emotions and a hefty dose of confusion.

A Matter of Significance

Five years ago, I had a dream not long after my grandmother passed. In that dream, a baby girl named Audrey played alongside my grandmother. This dream left a mark on me, compelling me to name my future daughter Audrey. I shared this dream with family members, making it clear that, one day, if blessed with a daughter, her name would be Audrey.

Fast forward to now, and I am indeed expecting a baby girl. True to my word, I planned to name her Audrey. However, things took a surprising turn during a recent family gathering.

The Unexpected Twist

At an Easter family gathering, my cousin, who is also expecting a baby girl, announced her chosen name: Audrey. Cue jaw-drop. Like a plot twist from a soap opera, I found myself bewildered. How could she pick the same name I had voiced years ago, influenced by my sentimental dream?

Maybe I’m overreacting. Some might argue that I should feel flattered, but it’s tough to see it that way. I even shared my baby registry in a family group page, where my cousin could have seen the name. Coincidence? You be the judge.

Seeking Advice

I shared my dilemma online, hoping for some clarity.

“Tell me your thoughts? Am I being too sensitive?” I asked. “I feel like I should not have shared her name with anyone. Lesson learned.”

Since my grandmother’s name wasn’t Audrey, I saw the baby from my dream as a divine sign. Unique, pure, and precious—characteristics I wanted to pass down to my daughter.

When Great Minds Think Alike

Surprisingly, my predicament isn’t isolated. Another tale surfaced on Reddit, where a family’s casual lunch led to another name conundrum.

In this story, the writer’s cousin revealed her love for the name Noah. Now, the writer is left grappling with the idea of losing a name cherished for years.

“My heart dropped instantly,” the writer expressed. “It’s the only name we agree on! We’re not pregnant yet, but if it’s a boy, it’s going to be Noah.”

Names, after all, carry more weight than merely distinguishing us in conversation. They’re potent symbols of our relationships, heritage, and aspirations.

Desperation Brews Creativity

Have you ever heard someone hint and dodge the big reveal of their baby name? It becomes a sublime mystery, building the suspense until the ultimate unveiling. Such was the case for another expectant cousin, who revealed her chosen name as Light Bringer. Yes, Light Bringer. Not everyone was thrilled.

The family’s conversation went something like this:

“She would say things like, ‘Children bring this’,” one relative shared. “My first guess was Hope. I imagined children bringing hope to the world.”

But what unfolded was far from conventional. Light Bringer, a name she stood firm on despite attempts to offer alternatives like Andromeda, Cassiopeia, and Starr.

The Ripple Effect

Even online, reactions ranged from criticism to empathetic understanding. Here are a few standout comments:

“At least it isn’t spelled Lyghte Bryngerr or something. Actually.. that might be better,” one Reddit user quipped.

Another user advised, “Just be there for the child when she gets tormented at school and resist the ‘I told you so’ impulse.”

Some even chimed in on the etiquette surrounding name choice, noting the bizarre lengths to which some would go—including accusations of jealousy and familial ostracism for dissenters.

What’s In a Name?

Name choices, it seems, can slice right to the heart of our values, identities, and familial bonds. It becomes a carefully played piano chord—a slight detour or simple key modulation can change the entire harmony of relationships.

As I navigate through this baby-naming drama—living in the shadows of expected joy and unexpected twists—I realize one thing for sure: the name we choose isn’t just a name; it’s the opening chapter in a book waiting to be written.

Will my cousin’s baby name wreak chaos or blend effortlessly into our family? Only time will tell. For now, let’s just hope everyone is writing their chapters with thoughtful intention and lots of love.

Photo of author
Shane is passionate about researching baby stuff for his baby girl. He worked for a premium brand consultancy. He runs the research on this site.